People talk
Our Guestbook
“ The owner Jay is top notch and his food is amazing and the quantity you receive is more than enough to fill your stomach. My granddaughter sure loves his bbq and his pizza will more than fill you up with all the toppings he uses so stop by and give him a try and his smoked bologna sandwich is the best I’ve ever had. ”
“ What can I say? Freshly prepared items full of flavor and cooked to your liking. It's our go to place in town. I have had the pizzas, canzone, pasta, wings, and Philly cheese steak sandwich. I have yet to be disappointed. The portion sizes are well worth the price. A 10 inc meat pizza can be shared or you'll have leftovers for 2-3 days. Ijs bring you're appetite. The staff is amazing!!! They are very attentive and personable. They always make us feel welcomed. I don't usually do reviews. I do feel that the owner and his staff deserve kudos for all their hard work and dedication. ”
“ Ok, where do I begin???? This was my first time in this establishment. I ordered the Philly Cheese Steak, and OH MY GOSH! It's the best one I've ever had in my LIFE!!! It was so full of flavor and juicy. And the size of this sandwich will blow your mind! I literally sat there for about 10 minutes trying to decide on what to order, but my eyes kept going back to the Philly. I was NOT DISAPPOINTED AT ALL! I even called the owner/manager to let him know how amazing this sandwich was. I can't wait to try a Cuban, reuban, the pastas, pizzas, and BBQ. And the BBQ smells phenomenal! They have it ALL! If you're in Madisonville, this is a must stop for lunch/dinner. I wish I could give them 20 stars. There's a difference in food when it's made by someone who knows and cares about what they're doing. And they know 100% what they're doing here! My new favorite #1 place to go now. ”
“ Awesome the calzones are fantastic. Prices we didn't think were bad for what you got. Will be back again. Waitress was very friendly went out of her way to make our visit pleasant. On a scale of 1 to 10 I would give them a 20 great food ”
“ This was like home for me! Been along time since I have had a GREAT Philly like home. The Alfredo was creamy and seasoned just right and the Chicken Tender wrap was HUGE!!! all could easily be split with two people so the pricing to me is awesome for the amount of food you get! Came back and ordered Wings, Fish, and an Italian Hoagie today. All so far have been Truly Delicious!!! We will be regulars. one more IMPORTANT thing the staff and owner make you feel like family and are always smiling. 10/10 see y'all soon!!! ”
“ Had a great experience today at Goodfellas New York Pizza & Grill. The food was great and the staff members were super friendly and welcoming! I highly recommend eating at Goodfellas! ”
“ First time going here today and I will say we were VERY pleased. The ladies up front were very nice and welcoming! The food was fresh, hot and delicious and The fried green tomatoes were amazing! Don’t listen to the bad reviews on here, considering it’s a freshly opened business there will obviously be kinks until things get settled down. People in Madisonville are just bitter... DON’T KNOCK IT TILL YOU TRY IT! ”
“ I ordered through slice and there was an issue with relaying my order to the restaurant. Long story short, I called and canceled my order after 2hours. I received a call from the owner (very unexpected) not only apologized for my issue but also went out of his way to make it right! Noone has ever made that effort before. I reordered my food and the pizza I received was unbelievable! I highly recommend eating any of the choices here and I have always recommended them to friends and neighbors! ”
About
Goodfellas New York Pizza & Grill - BBQ
Welcome to Goodfellas New York Pizza & Grill - BBQ, a culinary gem nestled in Madisonville, TN, where every dish is crafted with passion and a dedication to quality. Located at 4445 US-411, this establishment has quickly become a local favorite, thanks to its vibrant menu and the warmth of its owner, Jay, who is known for his top-notch service and commitment to satisfaction.
The menu at Goodfellas is a diverse offering that promises something for everyone. Insider tips reveal it’s not just about the pizza, even though the hearty toppings and generous sizes make it a standout. Patrons rave about the BBQ, calling it phenomenal. The reviews highlight dishes like the Philly Cheese Steak, which has won hearts for its rich flavors and juicy texture, making it a must-try for anyone visiting.
It’s the attention to detail that sets Goodfellas apart. Each dish is freshly prepared, bursting with flavor, and served in portions that ensure you leave satisfied. Customers such as Dawn Brown DeLaney have noted that even a small pizza can feed a crowd or keep you in leftovers for days, making it a great value.
The reviews do not stop there. Guests have shared delightful experiences, emphasizing the friendly staff and inviting atmosphere. The team goes above and beyond to make every patron feel like part of the family, ensuring that a meal here is not just about food, but about community.
As a food reviewer, I can't help but resonate with the passion reflected in each dish. The smoked bologna sandwich is a crowd favorite, and it comes highly recommended for those looking to explore the BBQ offerings. With a plethora of choices from calzones to pastas, every visit promises new discoveries.
In conclusion, Goodfellas New York Pizza & Grill - BBQ is more than just a restaurant—it's a destination for food lovers. Whether it’s your first visit or a return to savor beloved dishes, each excursion is sure to delight. If you find yourself in Madisonville, make it a point to stop by. Your taste buds will thank you!
Book a table